June 19, 2025
In our fast-paced work culture, the dynamics of credit and recognition can be complex. Imagine pouring your heart and soul into an innovative idea at work, only to watch your manager take the spotlight for it. It’s a frustrating scenario many employees face, leaving them questioning their value and contributions. I refer to such a manager as the “Plagiarizing Leader”TM.
P-L-A-G-I-A-R-I-Z-I-N-G Leader MethodTM (Used by Unethical Leaders)
(P) Pressure: Pressure to perform.
(L) Lack: Lack of innovation.
(A) Appearance: Appear more effective to their management.
(G) Gain: Gain recognition.
(I) Implicit: Implicit egotism.
(A) Appropriation: Appropriation of ideas to appear more competent.
(R) Reinforce: Reinforce their value to the organization.
(I) Interpretation: Interpretation of their role as “a manager” incorrectly.
(Z) Zest: Zest to maintain their status in the organization.
(I) Immense: Immense pressure to deliver results.
(N) Need: Personal Need for validation.
(G) Genuine: Genuine belief they substantially contributed.
The ”Plagiarizing Leader”TM is a philosophy concept coined by Lori Stith, The Stoicess®. The “P-L-A-G-I-A-R-I-Z-I-N-G Leader Method”TM, was developed by Lori Stith, The Stoicess® as a course for the Philosophy Leadership CoachTM. Lori Stith uses the “Plagiarizing Leader Method” to coach against unethical leadership.
——–
Navigating the workplace can often feel like maneuvering through a maze, with complex relationships and unwritten rules shaping the environment. From office politics to power hierarchies, understanding these dynamics is crucial for anyone looking to thrive professionally. When it comes to why managers might take credit for their subordinates’ ideas, the answer often lies within these intricate relationships and the pressures they entail.
In many organizations, the relationship between employees and their supervisors is not just about managing tasks but also about navigating power dynamics. Managers are often under immense pressure to deliver results and meet targets, which can sometimes lead to them appropriating ideas to appear more competent and effective. This isn’t always a reflection of their capabilities but rather a survival tactic in a high-pressure environment where the stakes are high.
Moreover, the culture within an organization can play a significant role in how credit is distributed. In competitive workplaces, the race to outshine others can lead to a culture where taking credit for someone else’s work becomes normalized. Understanding this context is essential for employees to interpret their experiences accurately and develop strategies to protect their intellectual contributions.
While it might be easy to assume that managers take credit for their employees’ ideas out of sheer selfishness, the reality is often more nuanced. Here are several more reasons why this happens, and understanding these can help employees navigate the situation more effectively.
Another reason is the pressure to perform. Managers are frequently judged on their team’s output, and the need to present innovative ideas and solutions can lead them to claim ownership of their subordinates’ contributions. This pressure is compounded by the expectations from upper management, who often reward visible achievements rather than the collaborative efforts behind them.
Insecurity is next. Some managers may feel threatened by the talent and creativity of their subordinates, fearing that acknowledging these contributions could undermine their authority or position. By taking credit for these ideas, they attempt to maintain their status and ensure that they remain indispensable to the organization.
The lack of clear communication channels and documentation can result in managers unintentionally taking credit. When ideas are shared informally or during impromptu meetings, it can be easy for the lines of ownership to blur. This ambiguity can lead to situations where managers genuinely believe they have contributed more than they actually did.
Furthermore, the act of taking credit for someone else’s ideas is not just a matter of ethics but also one deeply rooted in psychology. Understanding the psychological motivations behind this behavior can provide valuable insights into why it happens and how to address it. Cognitive biases play a significant role.
The self-serving bias, for instance, leads individuals to attribute successes to their abilities and efforts while blaming failures on external factors. This bias can cause managers to genuinely believe that the ideas they appropriated were influenced by their guidance and input, leading to an inflated sense of ownership.
Another psychological factor is the need for recognition and validation. In a competitive work environment, the desire to be acknowledged for achievements is strong. For some managers, this need can overshadow their ethical considerations, leading them to prioritize their recognition over fair credit distribution. This is often exacerbated by organizational cultures that reward individual successes over team efforts.
Furthermore, the phenomenon of implicit egotism can come into play. This refers to the unconscious tendency of people to prefer things that are associated with themselves. A manager might unconsciously gravitate toward ideas that align with their self-image, leading them to claim these ideas as their own. This unconscious bias highlights the complexity of the issue, as it can occur without deliberate intent to deceive.
Identifying when your ideas are being appropriated can be challenging, especially in environments where collaboration is encouraged. However, there are several signs that can help you recognize when your contributions are being overshadowed or outright stolen.
One clear sign is the absence of acknowledgment. If you notice that your ideas are frequently being presented by your manager without any mention of your contribution, it’s a strong indicator that credit is being misappropriated. This can be particularly evident in meetings or presentations where your input is crucial but not recognized.
Another sign is the pattern of exclusion. If you find yourself being excluded from follow-up discussions or meetings related to your ideas, it could be a deliberate attempt to minimize your involvement and visibility. This exclusion can prevent you from asserting your ownership and influence over the project.
Additionally, pay attention to the feedback loop. If your manager consistently takes your ideas and presents them as their own, there may be a lack of constructive feedback or collaboration. Instead of building on your contributions together, the manager might isolate your ideas and present them independently, which can be a red flag.
Safeguarding your intellectual contributions requires a proactive approach and strategic measures. By taking steps to protect your ideas, you can ensure that your hard work is recognized and credited appropriately.
Firstly, documentation is key. Keep a detailed record of your ideas, including dates, drafts, and any communications related to them. This documentation serves as evidence of your contributions and can be invaluable in situations where credit disputes arise. Use emails, notes, and project management tools to create a clear trail that links your work to the final outcomes.
Secondly, seek opportunities to present your ideas directly to key stakeholders. By taking the initiative to share your contributions in meetings, presentations, or reports, you can establish yourself as the originator of the idea. This approach not only increases your visibility but also makes it harder for others to claim credit for your work.
Collaboration and building alliances can also be effective. Engage with colleagues who can vouch for your contributions and support your claims when needed. By fostering a supportive network, you create a buffer against potential credit theft and reinforce the legitimacy of your ideas.
Clear and assertive communication is essential in ensuring that your contributions are recognized and credited appropriately. By articulating your ideas and achievements effectively, you can assert your ownership and reinforce your value within the organization.
Start by being proactive in sharing your ideas. Instead of waiting for opportunities to present themselves, take the initiative to communicate your contributions through various channels. This can include formal presentations, emails, and team meetings. By consistently highlighting your input, you establish a pattern of recognition.
When discussing your ideas, use “I” statements to assert ownership. For example, instead of saying, “We could consider this approach,” say, “I suggest we consider this approach.” This subtle shift in language emphasizes your role in generating the idea and makes it clear that you are the originator.
Additionally, seek feedback and acknowledgment from your peers and supervisors. After presenting an idea, follow up with colleagues to discuss their thoughts and gather input. This not only demonstrates your commitment to collaboration but also reinforces your role in the ideation process. By creating a dialogue around your contributions, you make it harder for others to overlook or misappropriate your work.
Addressing the issue of credit appropriation with your manager can be daunting, but it’s a necessary step in ensuring that your contributions are recognized. Approaching these conversations with tact and professionalism is crucial for a constructive outcome.
Begin by preparing your case. Gather evidence of your contributions, including documentation, emails, and any other relevant materials. Having concrete examples will strengthen your position and provide a clear basis for the discussion. Be specific about the instances where you feel your ideas were appropriated and the impact it has had on your recognition.
When initiating the conversation, choose an appropriate time and setting. A private and neutral environment can help facilitate an open and honest dialogue. Start by expressing your appreciation for the opportunities and support your manager has provided, and then transition to discussing your concerns. Frame the conversation in terms of your desire for clarity and collaboration rather than confrontation.
Use “I” statements to express your feelings and experiences. For example, say, “I felt that my contributions to the project were not fully acknowledged,” rather than, “You took credit for my work.” This approach reduces defensiveness and focuses on your perspective. Suggest ways to improve credit distribution, such as more transparent communication or formal acknowledgment in meetings. By proposing solutions, you demonstrate your commitment to a positive resolution.
Creating a supportive network of colleagues can be a powerful defense against idea appropriation and a means to amplify your contributions. By fostering strong professional relationships, you can build a community that recognizes and supports your work.
Start by identifying allies within your organization. These can be colleagues who have witnessed your contributions firsthand or those who share similar experiences. Building trust and rapport with these individuals can create a foundation for mutual support. Engage in open and honest conversations about your experiences and offer your support in return.
Collaboration is another key strategy. By working closely with your colleagues on projects and initiatives, you create opportunities for shared recognition. When multiple team members acknowledge each other’s contributions, it becomes more challenging for any single individual, including your manager, to appropriate credit.
Encourage a culture of recognition within your team. Celebrate each other’s achievements and give credit where it’s due. By modeling this behavior, you set a standard for fair credit distribution and create an environment where everyone feels valued. This collective effort can shift the organizational culture towards one that prioritizes and respects individual contributions.
Navigating the complexities of credit appropriation in the workplace can be challenging, but understanding the underlying reasons and taking proactive steps to protect your contributions can empower you to reclaim your voice and ensure your hard work is recognized.
By understanding workplace dynamics and the common reasons behind idea appropriation, you can better interpret your experiences and develop effective strategies. Recognizing the signs of idea theft and taking steps to protect your ideas through documentation and direct communication are crucial measures. Building a support network among colleagues and fostering a culture of recognition can further reinforce your efforts.
When addressing the issue with your manager, approach the conversation with preparation, tact, and professionalism. Throughout this process, maintain your confidence and commitment to fair credit distribution.
Ultimately, by taking these steps, you can ensure that your contributions shine where they deserve and continue to grow and thrive in your professional journey.
If you enjoyed this blog, CLICK The LINK BELOW for a list of all my books available on Amazon.
NOTE: Know that 100% Of Book Royalties From The Sales Of ALL My Books Are Donated To St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital.
MY BOOKS AVAILABLE AT AMAZON
I’m Lori Stith, The Stoicess,
and I believe in you.
Philosophy Leadership Coach
Christian Leadership, Career, & Life Coach
Lori Stith, CEO & The Stoicess
Stoic Matchmaker, LLC
Contact:
stoicmatchmaker. com;
1-833-MY-STOICESS
Lori Stith, REALTOR®
Long & Foster Realty,
Baltimore Regional Office,
1312 Bellona Ave
Lutherville, MD 21093
Contact:
410-979-8995 Cell;
410-583-9400 Office
August 21, 2025
August 18, 2025
